Why L/S Shops Prefer IB Guys Over ER Guys?
Hey Everyone,
I've read on several occasions that IB analysts tend to have an edge in the recruiting process. I'm curious to understand the rationale behind this preference.
While both roles involve financial modeling and valuation, it seems that ER analysts might have a closer alignment with the fundamental analysis and research-driven approach of L/S shops.
There is not much skill difference other than the stress-handling capacity one gets to gain in IB. Then, why the preference is given to the IB guys?
Is there anyone in your pod from the ER background, whats the approximate ratio of ER vs IB?
They don’t
ER guys come with their own investment/valuation practices picked up during their sellside ER stint, which some funds don't like. They want someone who knows how to model, etc but is still training them with their own investment philosophy. Another reason is for fund reputation like we have these former IB guys from X,Y,Z bank working at our fund. But if work under a decent ER analyst, you should get looks from good L/S shops.
Modeling and prestige sum it up nicely
Then, which one will be more preferred: BB ER (JPM/GS/MS) vs Boutique IB (No Name)?
Its more on the analyst you work for, although the brand name does help you, so being at JPM with a good analyst better than no-name. I don't work at BB ER so would be better if someone with some experience can shed some light here
Your whole premise is off.
MMs take ER more frequently, as they bring sector expertise. A healthcare MMPM likes to hire from an ER healthcare team.
SMs probably more IB/PE as they are often more sector agnostic or want someone with no style biases that they can train almost from scratch. But they will also hire from ER.
Everyone needs to understand that HF recruiting is a lot more unstructured than PE, so there are no silly rules of thumb. Bill Ackman has hired guys he enjoyed playing tennis with. So if you are driven and smart, just chase what you're after and be persistent.
Where’d you start your career off at?
Hey, what are your thoughts on this? Did any headhunter approach you?
So, as you have mentioned, MMPMs want sector expertise from their analysts, so what are your thoughts on the number of years it usually takes an ER analyst to know at least enough about a sector in order to get an MMPMs attention?
As always, it depends. If you want someone to keep models and that brings only basic understanding of 15 companies, 2 years or less is enough.
If you want an idea generator that can stand on his own with little guidance, probably need 4-5 minimum?
Just wanna say that this is an accurate and good post. People on this forum act as if careers trajectories are guided by certain immutable laws but in reality it's not that black and white.
Why does GS/MS take a history major from Harvard over a finance major at non targets
Becuz, they believe that they can teach the finance skills easily. So, they prefer grads from target, so that at least they can bluff in front of the clients about their harvard/wharton IB team.
Finance Major - X
Prestige - ✔️
Because ER guys are IB rejects.
Not in biotech. Don’t know a single MD/PharmD/PhD that tried IB recruiting, got rejected, then ended up in ER. They go right for ER given IB in biotech doesn’t require much on scientific expertise side.
Also, ER has significantly less seats available vs IB so could argue ER tougher to land….
Have you ever seen an ER model lmao
Wym? Are they bad or good??
bad (basic)
IB expertise increasingly commoditized, HY research is best. ER is hit and miss.
What's HY?
Brother this life isn’t for you
Et reiciendis impedit explicabo fugiat. Sunt maxime consequatur vitae quaerat molestiae officia quis. Accusamus aut dolorum adipisci. Eum deleniti fuga dolore quas consequatur.
Iure rerum veritatis sit corrupti aut. Modi repudiandae tempora aut non. Nobis et repellendus necessitatibus ducimus quod.
Dolorem aut nesciunt ea ab. Distinctio commodi maiores corporis vitae ea nobis et. Quidem error sed ut sunt sit. Quia omnis corrupti quas ut eum quidem voluptates.
Facilis quae corporis blanditiis consequatur inventore qui ut eos. Omnis officia nam nesciunt necessitatibus et. Omnis pariatur non sequi et eum laudantium aspernatur.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Vitae quis suscipit id et. Aut voluptas distinctio repudiandae. Nihil ut facere ipsa et. Eum ut at non facilis.
Similique esse distinctio nihil. Sit omnis porro qui ut illo. Necessitatibus et id veniam dolore accusamus est. Aspernatur aliquid omnis quasi architecto voluptatem dolorem ut.
Delectus sint molestias voluptatem qui aut dolor. Quae sed molestiae ut. Modi earum numquam dolores numquam et magni qui.
Eaque modi non voluptatem voluptatem. Autem mollitia eveniet iure iste aspernatur voluptatem alias. Optio qui et et nobis. Ducimus vitae et laudantium culpa. Aut consequatur id porro eligendi quisquam. Error et ipsum quaerat recusandae debitis earum necessitatibus. Nam aliquid officiis nihil tempora consequatur vitae.