NYC SA Recruiting 2012-2013

Couldn't find a thread like this (besides the HK/Sing one), but thought it would be good for people to know what stage in the process most of the banks are in. Post updates as you hear back from various BBs and the main boutiques/MM firms in terms of 1st round interviews, superdays, etc. This is for non OCR and also non-accelerated processes, so just the general application process timing. Post if you have any updates.

Morgan Stanley- Superdays
JPM- Superdays
Deutsche Bank- 1st rounds
Credit Suisse- 1st rounds
Goldman Sachs- Superdays
BAML- Superdays/2nd rounds
Barclays- Superdays
Citi- super day Feb 8
UBS- 1st rounds out
RBS- 1st rounds out (Feb 1, 5) superday Feb 15 scheduled
RBC- Superdays
Lazard- 1st rounds out
Evercore- 1st rounds
Greenhill- 1st rounds out
Perella Weinberg- 1st rounds
Moelis- Superdays
Jefferies- Superdays
KBW- Super- Done
Sandler O'Neill- Done
Houlihan Lokey- 1st rounds
Brown Brothers Harriman- Done
Piper Jaffray- Done
Blackstone- Superdays
Centerview Partners- 1st rounds out
Lazard MM- Done
Gleacher- Superdays
Cowen- 1st rounds being sent out
Wells Fargo-Done
HSBC- first rounds out
Rothschild- Done
Oppenheimer- 1st rounds being sent out
Nomura- 1st rounds
Macquarie- 1st rounds
BMO- 1st rounds
Miller Buckfire- 1st rounds
Peter Solomon- Pending
Imperial Capital- Pending
CIBC- Pending
BNP Paribas- Pending
TD Securities- 1st rounds
Duff & Phelps- Pending
Canaccord- Pending
BBT- Pending
Cantor Fitzgerald- Pending
Wedbush- Pending
Needham- Pending
JMP Group- 1st rounds ou
Sagent- Done
Stifel- 1st rounds out

 

Deadlines for referral? Not sure what that means/have not heard of that.

On another note:

Lazard MM begins it's recruiting process after the holidays (potentially actual Lazard as well?)

Evercore will begin their process with first round interviews in early January

Moelis will kick off their process in the next few weeks, though possibly not until beginning of January

 

Question if anyone can answer-

The Nomura app has a section where it says- do you know anyone at the firm? It also has a separate "how did you hear about us" where employee referral is an option. I emailed last spring a guy in their London office, and I'm wondering if it would be appropriate to put him under the first section and just say he is an alum from my school. I would probably email him either way to let him know I applied/set up a chance to speak with him

 

If you still keep in contact with him, then yes

Black Jack:
Question if anyone can answer-

The Nomura app has a section where it says- do you know anyone at the firm? It also has a separate "how did you hear about us" where employee referral is an option. I emailed last spring a guy in their London office, and I'm wondering if it would be appropriate to put him under the first section and just say he is an alum from my school. I would probably email him either way to let him know I applied/set up a chance to speak with him

.
 

The Wells deadline was for S&T only. At least that's how it was at my school. They told us if we applied online to their website, rather than through OCR, we'd be auto-screened. But if this is for non-OCR than that makes sense

"You rarely have time for everything you want in this life, so you need to make choices. And hopefully your choices can come from a deep sense of who you are." - Mister Rogers
 

I was told to expect an email regarding the first stage of interviews for WF.The application due on the 3rd and 4th was for the their entire IBD.

 
couchy:
imperial capital, lincoln international, CIBC, TD, Canaccord, Needham, BNP, cantor fitzgerald, Duff & Phelps, Ray Jay, Wedbush, Stephens, BBT, Suntrust, Lazard MM are pretty good bank to add...

Will add, though Lazard MM is on there and Lincoln has a tiny NY presence and Suntrust has like no NYC presence. Anyone know if Nomura prompts everyone for the online reasoning/logic tests?

 
MinneBanker:
Black Jack,

What was the Nomura test like?

2 parts

Part 1- Standard online math/logic tests- reading percentages, graphs, tables, charts, etc. 20 questions 20 mins; a little time pressed but not bad

Part 2- Picture analogies. Gives you a sequence of pictures and asks you to say which would be next. 22 questions in 10 minutes I think. These can be fairly tough (kind of a either you see it or don't sort of thing). Unsure how much stock they even put into these tests. I imagine if you have a referral they look to make sure that you are competent and passed them.

 

Most BB's are kicking off first rounds at targets second week of Jan...with non-target recruiting early Feb

FYI GS non-target recruiting is happening alongside OCR

 
Mark2010:
Most BB's are kicking off first rounds at targets second week of Jan...with non-target recruiting early Feb

FYI GS non-target recruiting is happening alongside OCR

Don't believe that this is true. Haven't heard of different time schedules for non-targets vs. targets- everything should be kicking off with first rounds in the first 2 weeks of January and superdays the last 2 weeks of the month (and beginning week of Feb).

 
Black Jack:
Mark2010:
Most BB's are kicking off first rounds at targets second week of Jan...with non-target recruiting early Feb

FYI GS non-target recruiting is happening alongside OCR

Don't believe that this is true. Haven't heard of different time schedules for non-targets vs. targets- everything should be kicking off with first rounds in the first 2 weeks of January and superdays the last 2 weeks of the month (and beginning week of Feb).

You're talking to the wrong people

 

Bump- has anyone heard anything from any of these places?

I've managed to get some sort of decent referral at most of them, so I should be able to keep this as updated as possible, though who knows how strong those will be and any help is still appreciated; didn't apply to the bottom 10-15 on the list.

Edit: Saw someone recently added a Lazard MM review for 2012 SA- I'm thinking that was from last year, as I'd been told by an MD at the firm that they would start the process after the holidays- if anyone knows anything though, let me know.

 
couchy:
does that mean apps are clsoed for Jefferies?

I haven't checked, but I wouldn't assume so. Some of these places don't close apps online until like March (but fill up all spots months earlier).

Jefferies looks like it is still up upon checking; that said, I would turn it in asap. They still have openings online for European interns, but I know that that has already been wrapped up.

 
TheBlueCheese:
theboi123 - you sure BAML 1st rounds are out? Are you at a target? Perhaps I'm wrong but I doubt any banks have been sending emails for first rounders Dec ~25th - Jan 1st...

I am not a target, but I would assume non-targets would receive their interviews after targets. I actually heard on December 17th. However, I have not received a date. We are supposed to get a specific date by the 4th.

As for Citi, the superday is on the 18th of January.

 
theboi123:
TheBlueCheese:
theboi123 - you sure BAML 1st rounds are out? Are you at a target? Perhaps I'm wrong but I doubt any banks have been sending emails for first rounders Dec ~25th - Jan 1st...

I am not a target, but I would assume non-targets would receive their interviews after targets. I actually heard on December 17th. However, I have not received a date. We are supposed to get a specific date by the 4th.

As for Citi, the superday is on the 18th of January.

And are invites out for the Citi superday?

 
Mtntop990:
Can anyone confirm status changed to "under review" at GS?
My status is still application received - is that not a good sign?
 
xoxonino:
Mtntop990:
Can anyone confirm status changed to "under review" at GS?
My status is still application received - is that not a good sign?

I got an e-mail for a first round from GS today but online it still says application received so I'm not sure it's connected!

 

When somebody says "X Superday is out", does that mean the candidates have already been given invites or that the dates have just been set?

 
TheBlueCheese:
wallstreetm10:
I had my baml first round already--were superday invites sent out for that? (IBD SA)

Are you at a target? Did you do this through OCR?

nope! i'm at a non-target school and I did it through their website.

 
Black Jack:
A Fellow Linguist:
Does anybody know if Oppenheimer takes any SAs, and if so, how to submit an application to join their firm?

They definitely do take a handful (same as most other banks their size maybe 10-12). Unfortunately they are not accepting applications online, and their drop through referral is over.

Thanks, Black Jack. You're a good guy for keeping this thread updated. I'll be sure to chime in if I hear anything, although I'm mostly going through OCR.
 
Black Jack:
Cowen and Qatalyst are both closed

Believe Evercore and Moelis are as well, but I won't update until I get confirmation (you may still be able to apply, but they are beginning interviews first week of Jan)

evercore definitely isn't closed. my target has resume drops next week.
 
kidflash:
Black Jack:
Cowen and Qatalyst are both closed

Believe Evercore and Moelis are as well, but I won't update until I get confirmation (you may still be able to apply, but they are beginning interviews first week of Jan)

evercore definitely isn't closed. my target has resume drops next week.

FYI- this thread is for non OCR. A lot of banks will close for non-targets (non ocr recruiting) well before they do their OCR (which they hold spots for). Robert Baird for example finished non-core recruiting in November but recruits OCR at a few schools in January.

 
TheBlueCheese:
Black Jack do you have friends at all these places? Have you heard from anywhere personally? Mind giving us a brief intro on your background? (non-target? ~GPA, etc...)

I go to what I guess would be considered a target or semi-target and my GPA is around 3.7- some have higher, some have lower. Everything I have updated (besides what others have posted) has been personal information I have received through some contact or another at the bank. Where there weren't alums at the banks I tried (and sometimes failed) to cold call the bank and ask to speak with those in charge of recruiting for SA or email someone at the bank from a similar background/school as myself. Came into the recruiting season with the attitude that there was no reason to not get at least a first round interview at most everywhere- which can be done with decent stats from a solid school by just getting someone to refer you to HR. Was unsuccessful in these attempts at a few places, which others have fortunately kept updated for me- Citi, BAML, HSBC, Piper Jaffray were some of a few that I had to apply straight through the online app and cross my fingers. Nonetheless, I'm still on the job hunt like the rest of you, so whether I had a good strategy remains to be seen.

 
Black Jack:
TheBlueCheese:
Black Jack do you have friends at all these places? Have you heard from anywhere personally? Mind giving us a brief intro on your background? (non-target? ~GPA, etc...)

I go to what I guess would be considered a target or semi-target and my GPA is around 3.7- some have higher, some have lower. Everything I have updated (besides what others have posted) has been personal information I have received through some contact or another at the bank. Where there weren't alums at the banks I tried (and sometimes failed) to cold call the bank and ask to speak with those in charge of recruiting for SA or email someone at the bank from a similar background/school as myself. Came into the recruiting season with the attitude that there was no reason to not get at least a first round interview at most everywhere- which can be done with decent stats from a solid school by just getting someone to refer you to HR. Was unsuccessful in these attempts at a few places, which others have fortunately kept updated for me- Citi, BAML, HSBC, Piper Jaffray were some of a few that I had to apply straight through the online app and cross my fingers. Nonetheless, I'm still on the job hunt like the rest of you, so whether I had a good strategy remains to be seen.

Best of luck man! Do post in success stories when you get though this.

 
Black Jack:
TheBlueCheese:
Black Jack do you have friends at all these places? Have you heard from anywhere personally? Mind giving us a brief intro on your background? (non-target? ~GPA, etc...)

I go to what I guess would be considered a target or semi-target and my GPA is around 3.7- some have higher, some have lower. Everything I have updated (besides what others have posted) has been personal information I have received through some contact or another at the bank. Where there weren't alums at the banks I tried (and sometimes failed) to cold call the bank and ask to speak with those in charge of recruiting for SA or email someone at the bank from a similar background/school as myself. Came into the recruiting season with the attitude that there was no reason to not get at least a first round interview at most everywhere- which can be done with decent stats from a solid school by just getting someone to refer you to HR. Was unsuccessful in these attempts at a few places, which others have fortunately kept updated for me- Citi, BAML, HSBC, Piper Jaffray were some of a few that I had to apply straight through the online app and cross my fingers. Nonetheless, I'm still on the job hunt like the rest of you, so whether I had a good strategy remains to be seen.

Best of luck man! Do post in success stories when you get though this.

 
MinneBanker:
Lincoln told me that they are exclusively hiring from targets...so yeah. I guess that would count as drop ended?

I didn't put Lincoln on here since most of it is for their Chicago office. As for that- don't worry about it; I did an interview with them as well and was told the exact same thing. The interviewer was pretty sympathetic really stressed that I should apply for the full time position in the fall because they have more spots then and can take non-core kids. It's rough, but just is what it is I guess.

 

Is this thread just for IBD?

"My dear, descended from the apes! Let us hope it is not true, but if it is, let us pray that it will not become generally known."
 
couchy:
anyone know if raymond james, william blair, KBW, or brown brothers are still accepting summer analyst apps?

I have no info on Raymond James BBH is closed (finished accepting last week I believe or earlier in December)

KBW and Blair seem to be running very informal processes this year- they have definitely already done first round interviews for many candidates, but it might be on a sort of 'rolling basis' in that if you have the right people see your resume/application now it won't be too late to still get into the process.

 

Ok, i figured. My school doesn't have any alumni (wtf?) at WB, and I emailed HR and was told to "apply via OCR" that didn't exist so I guess cold calling it is...

 
MinneBanker:
Ok, i figured. My school doesn't have any alumni (wtf?) at WB, and I emailed HR and was told to "apply via OCR" that didn't exist so I guess cold calling it is...

I think you should have time. Their OCR hasn't taken place yet, and they told me the super day would be mid/late January, so if they are interested there would surely be time to squeeze in a quick phone interview.

 
Black Jack:
vegankid:
Dinged for JP Morgan Private Bank Summer Associate NY. :(

Win some and lose some, man. Keep on going and brush it off- something will work out.

Thanks! :)

 

My guess is most of these banks have closed apps for non-targets (unofficially) and are just leaving the online portal for target students with OCR...

 

My guess is most of these banks have closed apps for non-targets (unofficially) and are just leaving the online portal for target students with OCR...

 
Pienaar21:
Pienaar21:
Are applications for Citi completely closed??

If anyone can answer this I would really, really appreciate it..

Just checked for you and it looks like the positions are still online, so you should be able to apply for a bit.

Whether they are still looking at resumes dropped by non-targets online is another story.

If you are super interested though, you should go check on their site.

 

Does anyone know if William Blair has started recruiting yet? I don't see a posting on their website (HR is unhelpful and refers me to website.)

Does that mean their process is just later?

*edit: Contacted HR and they said they are hiring from their targets (OCR) only....so nevermind!

 
MinneBanker:
Does anyone know if William Blair has started recruiting yet? I don't see a posting on their website (HR is unhelpful and refers me to website.)

Does that mean their process is just later?

*edit: Contacted HR and they said they are hiring from their targets (OCR) only....so nevermind!

I interviewed them (not a target there) back in December, and they said similar things. Basically said they might take 16 kids for the summer and 12 spots were for target schools. Had some pretty high up referrals, so I'm hoping to move on to their super day later in the month, but who knows, crossing my fingers.

 
jasper90:
i got an email from bofa to fill out some SA IB form on survey monkey.....not sure what this indicates

I just received this email too.... idk what it means though

 

I didn't put it on here because IB operations are mostly out of Atlanta/down south, but for anyone who is interested, STRH is almost exclusively recruiting from their core schools (mainly the southern targets). I was referred by a very senior person at the firm in the division and told to reach back out in March to see if they were looking to fill any other spots.

 
Black Jack:
I didn't put it on here because IB operations are mostly out of Atlanta/down south, but for anyone who is interested, STRH is almost exclusively recruiting from their core schools (mainly the southern targets). I was referred by a very senior person at the firm in the division and told to reach back out in March to see if they were looking to fill any other spots.

yea it's going to be extra tough for non-targets this year. seems like most firms aren't looking to hire outside of their target school lists.

 
TheBlueCheese:
any non-targets here who applied to BAML not get one of those survey emails?

I'm a non-target who had a first round and hasn't received the survey monkey.

 
MinneBanker:
I am a semi-target. no email :( I am assuming that email = good thing

Who knows- I wouldn't worry too much about it. It's just one bank, and even if it doesn't work out there will be others.

For all you guys in the recruiting process, best of luck. For all the places you apply and all the rejections you might get, it only takes 1 offer- easy to forget.

 

BlackJack, just to keep you updated on a few of the smaller banks- I was notified this week by both Oppenheimer and Cowen about 1st round interviews, so I'm assuming all 1st round interview notifications are out for those two firms

 
jcas5585:
BlackJack, just to keep you updated on a few of the smaller banks- I was notified this week by both Oppenheimer and Cowen about 1st round interviews, so I'm assuming all 1st round interview notifications are out for those two firms

Thanks for the update. Oppenheimer I believe is doing 1st rounds on a rolling basis, so I don't think that is fully closed yet. I will update Cowen, though I believe that may be rolling as well.

On another note- Centerview 1st rounds are out.

 
MinneBanker:
Harris Williams isn't on the list but they are done I think. Maybe very late in the process

Spoke to a friend with a contact there, he said he's pretty sure they're not even "close to done" but are underway.

 

Finally contacted by a recruiter from Citi for a phone interview after an MD that I met at an event last month connected us. Applied in late November for Summer Associate position but checked my status on their recruitment page and it still says that my application has been received and under consideration.

Will update you guys after I speak with the recruiter.

 

Are those deadlines only for NYC offices for those companies or just the overall deadlines for online applications?

I went to a UChicago JP Morgan meeting on Jan 10th and got a sheet saying that the deadline is Jan 11th for IBD, S&T and Public Finance. So I am not sure if the deadline is for Chicago only or any application online. Does anybody know how that works?

 
Beny23:
Are those deadlines only for NYC offices for those companies or just the overall deadlines for online applications?

I went to a UChicago JP Morgan meeting on Jan 10th and got a sheet saying that the deadline is Jan 11th for IBD, S&T and Public Finance. So I am not sure if the deadline is for Chicago only or any application online. Does anybody know how that works?

I'd say its for UChicago's OCR. So if you go to UChicago, those are the deadline dates. Otherwise, its another date, which I'm guessing is the 15th.

 
Beny23:
Are those deadlines only for NYC offices for those companies or just the overall deadlines for online applications?

I went to a UChicago JP Morgan meeting on Jan 10th and got a sheet saying that the deadline is Jan 11th for IBD, S&T and Public Finance. So I am not sure if the deadline is for Chicago only or any application online. Does anybody know how that works?

The deadlines I have been posting are either for online app or in the case of interviews purely for NYC offices.

 

Soluta voluptatibus esse architecto rem. Dolores enim vitae vel eum est dolore perferendis. Amet ipsam voluptas mollitia voluptatem aliquam aut voluptas voluptas.

Aliquam ab sequi maiores ipsam facilis. Nihil quisquam porro non nihil mollitia maiores facilis sed. Asperiores occaecati nobis nihil deleniti velit minus. Placeat voluptas doloribus doloribus adipisci. Tempore ullam repellendus incidunt ipsam occaecati.

 

Aspernatur quam illum saepe vitae aut sed. Accusantium suscipit ut corporis et sed quos. Corrupti suscipit neque reiciendis nemo veritatis molestias quas. Provident voluptatem animi nobis culpa numquam.

Ea quam fuga ducimus aspernatur omnis eligendi. Vel explicabo autem nisi eos est. Exercitationem est consectetur deleniti magni eius sint et.

Quasi ab velit officia magni nam. Ut ipsa qui fuga aliquid libero repellat quod.

 

Sit enim sed ipsum quis perspiciatis aut sint. Incidunt quod quo placeat assumenda tenetur. Voluptatem dolores expedita quidem commodi id praesentium repudiandae. Voluptatem libero dolores molestiae.

Voluptatem quia in tempora rerum et ut vitae. Ullam atque reprehenderit necessitatibus ut illo saepe. Quia tenetur rerum dolorum numquam ex sit modi.

Voluptatem perferendis est nobis officia quas. Ad et sint dicta sit eaque quis.

 

Sunt qui voluptatem voluptatem dolores quia sunt necessitatibus. Aut ullam quis voluptatum harum alias quia est. Distinctio alias qui eos. Culpa ullam in accusamus fugit dolores consequatur labore.

Ut repellat odio aspernatur harum facilis. Veniam aliquid consequuntur fuga sit. Consequatur excepturi temporibus earum voluptatibus. Et sit maiores iste est.

Qui laboriosam itaque dolorem voluptas exercitationem eos repellendus. Fugit perspiciatis dolor est voluptatem. Ipsa voluptas animi sed. Non aut sit excepturi ut esse quis consequatur aut.

 

Quibusdam ut qui id et et. Ab porro aliquid rerum molestiae soluta quos qui. Voluptatem suscipit necessitatibus ea. Molestiae porro corporis placeat ut. Officiis repellat illum corporis in consequatur labore. Et illum aut veritatis voluptas autem.

Repellat nemo possimus et. Aut illum et iure nisi aut veniam quis laborum. Eligendi est quae illo amet voluptatum. Et odio et explicabo a amet vel iste.

Illum temporibus ut ea corporis iure incidunt ipsam. Fuga quae debitis atque odit. Voluptas nemo vero libero id tempore voluptatibus.

Adipisci libero omnis labore nostrum laboriosam magnam quo. Ea quae molestiae delectus. Nihil repellendus nisi nisi omnis impedit distinctio.

 

Atque labore eius omnis eum recusandae ut inventore rerum. Saepe eveniet assumenda porro laudantium voluptatem id quia. Inventore sit quia consequatur vitae deleniti eaque dolores quae.

At tempora qui possimus perspiciatis laboriosam. Magni alias impedit distinctio voluptatem ad est maxime. Nulla officiis et voluptatibus quo voluptatem et ab.

Velit aut nihil esse nemo eius similique sit. Occaecati quae quas vel. Sapiente ex vitae asperiores ab. Cupiditate corporis voluptatem cupiditate sit.

 

Veniam veritatis culpa et ad quas quia. Quia non sit vero suscipit ut similique debitis libero. Sed consectetur qui occaecati itaque molestiae. Eaque iure corrupti ipsum repellendus.

Veritatis similique dolorum dolore maxime vel dolor corporis sint. Voluptas illo nostrum eligendi facere. A odit atque officia qui atque et. Enim voluptatem et iusto quo iste quod ut. Unde dignissimos et rerum quam necessitatibus libero modi facere. Ex consequatur sit voluptas reprehenderit sapiente suscipit a nihil.

Quaerat non consequuntur voluptates id accusantium eveniet. Commodi dicta quia ut magnam. Officia reiciendis minima id aliquid. Eius ratione cumque quis nesciunt repellendus quia.

 

Quaerat autem praesentium provident vel est. Repellat nostrum non neque natus quo itaque. Ea dolor aliquam hic natus.

Quidem cum consequatur iste animi facilis. Aut molestiae sit quo nam ea ut. Quam possimus saepe et. Consequatur reiciendis unde at possimus cumque.

Aliquid illum qui magnam iusto labore perferendis. Qui et doloremque nam ipsam quia.

Possimus necessitatibus vero et est culpa impedit. Voluptas dolorem architecto et. Dolore quod iste harum quidem sed. Eius non voluptas aut dolor. Rerum consequatur quisquam illo et.

 

Rerum voluptate aut facilis. Labore sequi ab aperiam aut neque non. Impedit officiis sit dolores fugiat sed animi.

Et delectus quia iste dolorem eaque voluptates nulla. Aperiam autem cupiditate autem non ullam est. Ea dolores quia totam sed voluptas rem dolor esse. Placeat ullam vel placeat occaecati reprehenderit saepe. Voluptas accusamus placeat sed quas harum qui omnis. In et saepe sequi sed eum rerum facilis. Dolorem repellendus quasi quia.

Career Advancement Opportunities

June 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Perella Weinberg Partners New 98.9%
  • Lazard Freres 01 98.3%
  • Harris Williams & Co. 24 97.7%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

June 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 19 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.9%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 97.7%
  • Moelis & Company 01 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

June 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.9%
  • Perella Weinberg Partners 18 98.3%
  • Goldman Sachs 16 97.7%
  • Moelis & Company 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

June 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (22) $375
  • Associates (93) $259
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (14) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (69) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (206) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (149) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”